Maybe the issue is not historical accuracy, but the time in which a movie is released braveheart was wildly successful upon its initial release, and it has maintained that popularity over time. The immortality of william wallace the history press. The debatable importance of historical accuracy in period films from left. The debatable importance of historical accuracy in period. Mel gibsons film braveheart is both one of the most celebrated and one of the most reviled pieces of historical filmmaking ever. The film depicts the life of wallace leading the scots in the first war of scottish independence against king edward i of england. Starting at the beginning, where they actually tell you theyre planning on telling you lies for the entire movie, we are told the date is 1280 ad, and the narrator says. William wallace was immortalised in the 1995 film braveheart, but has it. The inaccuracies are everywhere, from the general timeline to the characters themselves.
All the historical inaccuracies in braveheart we just cant ignore. Yet the wild liberties it took with history have led it to be repeatedly panned by historians and critics. Mel gibson, sophie marceau, patrick mcgoohan period of history in focus. The movie is exceptionally accurate when compared with other historical movies. Til braveheart has been described as one of the most historically inaccurate modern films. Braveheart the 10 historical inaccuracies you need to. The immortality of william wallace scottish hero william wallace was hanged, drawn and quartered on 23 august 6. With mel gibson, sophie marceau, patrick mcgoohan, angus macfadyen. Based on the 2009 kathryn stockett novel of the same name, the movie has inspired internet ire, and for good reasonit shows us the kind of problems that can arise when a film meant to be historical fiction loses touch with the actual history its.
Braveheart, historical accuracy, and sexual violence anonymous college. Personally, im afraid im too much a stickler for truth to sit through such a gory mutilation of the. To be 100% historically accurate, our movie would have to be 7. The cruelest irony of braveheart is that it completely slanders the man that actually bore the films title name. And still others fall in the middle of that scale, containing historical accuracy mixed with fantasy. Elizabeth ewan describes braveheart as a film which almost totally sacrifices historical accuracy for epic adventure. Indeed, according to historian elizabeth ewan, the film almost totally sacrifices historical accuracy for epic adventure. Sharon krossa pointed out that in the film, the events arent accurate, the dates arent accurate, the characters arent accurate, the names arent accurate, the clothes arent accuratein short, just.
William wallace the movie braveheart, directed by mel gibson and released in 1995, is an epic tale about a scottish hero named william wallace. Apr, 2010 braveheart, although still admired by many, falls down on many issues with regards to historical accuracy, many of which will be examined in this investigation. Mel gibsons oscarwinning movie braveheart was released in 1996. Historical inaccuracies from 11 oscarwinning movies that. Though cameron has written and directed an epic fictional love story set during an iconic historical event, the former unfortunately occupies a majority of the film. After reading through the answers i notice that no one has mentioned the biggest howler in the move this is probably mentioned in the video the major battle depicted in the movie where wallace defeats the english is the battle of stirling bridg. Wallace was a scottish knight who became a hero in the scottish rebellions against the english in the late th and early 14th century. Jul 30, 2008 braveheart won five oscars, including best picture. As recently as 2009, the times of london called braveheart the secondmost inaccurate historical film of all time.
This essay describes some of the many historical problems with the film braveheart. However, changes have been made to make the film more entertaining and romantic. The many historical facts the movie braveheart got wrong. After all, historical events and people arent known for being simple, clearcut or morally unambiguous. The film braveheart, to which clann tartan members should need no introduction, has been nominated for academy awards and rereleased, which prompts me to do something i should have done when it was released the first time. The epic movie helped along by a solid cast, bloodily rousing battle scenes, james horner s swooningly romantic score and the awesome landscapes of the scottish. The same standards of historical accuracy which are to expected for one do not apply to the other. Braveheart, historical epic film, released in 1995, that was directed by and starred mel gibson and was loosely based on the story of thcentury scottish leader william wallace. Director and actor mel gibsons portrayal of scotlands hero william wallace mesmerized audiences and won the movie five oscars the film is set in thcentury scotland, when wallace returns to his homeland to find it oppressed and taken over by the brutal, pagan king of england, edward i. One historian took particular exception to the costumes and compared it to, a film about colonial america showing the colonial men wearing 20th century business suits, but with the jackets worn backtofront. Though ofarrells claim is on the harsh side, the film is littered with. For a controversial episode of history such as the crusades, the issue of historical accuracy becomes even more relevant. The 1995 film braveheart has been a hit largely because of the ways in which it makes an older world come alive. Please see my policy if you wish to cite any part of this essay.
Mar 28, 2019 i am part of a facebook group of nearly 120,000 members who are interested in british medieval history, and mentioning braveheart is akin to the most severe swear word. All the historical inaccuracies in braveheart we just cant. Braveheart has been called one of the least accurate historical movies ever made, a harsh critique when you consider films like 10,000 bc, pocahontas, jfk, and pearl harbor. Indeed, mel gibson has caught a lot of flak from historians for a number. Historical inaccuracies in the movie braveheart free. The far side of the worlds historical accuracy is a matter of some debate simply because of the nature of the films plot. One person may watch braveheart, a classic tale about a scottish revolution led by the legendary william wallace,and love the kilt claddenscotsmen, feeling that it adds to the feel of the movie. A reckless disregard for historical accuracy didnt prevent mel gibsons twodimensional tale of scots hero william wallace from snagging both best film and best director oscars. One medieval epic wins in a scottish history smackdown over weapons, clothing, costumes, and. Taking place in an ancient scotland, the films psychological realities are very different from the historical truths, although audiences in. Gibson received an oscar for best director, and the film received four additional oscars including best picture and five. Director and actor mel gibsons portrayal of scotlands hero william wallace mesmerized audiences and won the movie five oscars. How historically accurate was james camerons titanic. The scottish war for independence roughly 12965 most people i have spoken to know that braveheart is not a film rife with historical accuracy.
Braveheart, the 1995 action drama produced by and featuring mel gibson in the title role of scotsman william wallace, was a commercial success. The epic movie helped along by a solid cast, bloodily rousing battle scenes, james horner s swooningly romantic score and the awesome landscapes of the scottish highlands and erm ireland. Top 5 historical inaccuracies in braveheart duration. There is absolutely, undoubtedly zero fact outside the basic requirements. Scottish hero william wallace was hanged, drawn and quartered on 23 august 6. Personally, im afraid im too much a stickler for truth to sit through such a gory mutilation of the past, but if youre more freespirited than. Most of the characters in this movie never really existed although some are based on certain archetypes, and the major conflict that the movie portrayed is also entirely fictional.
When braveheart came out in 1995, it was an instant success. After all, if youre capable of separating enjoyment of history from enjoyment of an exciting adventure film, why not. The braveheart has returned glorious historical spectacles on a menu, however, it. The good news is, william wallace was an actual scottish rebel who became a symbol of resistance against the english during the reign of king william i until his execution in 5. It is quite possible that it is exactly this films lack of historical accuracy, aside from the general historical setting and character names, that makes this movie so great. Apr 23, 2008 historian elizabeth ewan describes braveheart as a film which almost totally sacrifices historical accuracy for epic adventure. To many viewers, braveheart is believed to be historically accurate, and in many ways it is. Robert the bruce was a conflicted nobleman, but he highly favored the scottish side and did not fight against wallace at falkirk, nor did he or his father have anything to do with the betrayal of wallace and his subsequent execution bruce is considered a national hero in scotland. If he had stayed within the limits of the blind harrys song he would had more to do with history.
Sharon krossa pointed out that in the film, the events arent accurate, the dates arent accurate, the characters arent. Film locations for braveheart in ireland and scotland. David bruce, ronald reagan, errol flynn and william lundigan in the 1940 film santa fe trail. Each one of those movies has varying degrees of historical accuracy. In retrospect it seems vaguely humorous that the future american president ronald reagan should have found himself cast as the celebrityseeking martinet george armstrong. I would also remind you that braveheart was a theatrical film release, not a documentary.
My feelings on historical accuracy in film and television are mixed, and so i thought it would be best to break this up into reasons for and against historical accuracy. I am part of a facebook group of nearly 120,000 members who are interested in british medieval history, and mentioning braveheart is akin to the most severe swear word. A foot sandstone sculpture of gibson as wallace was placed in the car park of stirlings wallace. Braveheart, although still admired by many, falls down on many issues with regards to historical accuracy, many of which will be examined in this investigation. Gibson both directed and starred in the 1995 film that depicted the true story of a rebellious scottish warrior, william wallace, as he led an uprising against the king of england, edward i, during the th century. Get a 100% unique essay on historical inaccuracies in the movie braveheart. The film is set in thcentury scotland, when wallace returns to his homeland to find it oppressed and taken over by the brutal, pagan king of england. When his secret bride is executed for assaulting an english soldier who tried to rape her, william wallace begins a revolt against king edward i of england. One could theorize that there is a purpose to taking creative license with history. It won multiple oscars, praised by film critics and adored by audiences.
All the historical inaccuracies in braveheart we just can. Braveheart was named the worst film to ever win an oscar by empire magazine in 2005. Its also an extremely historically inaccurate film, but that doesnt devalue it as a cinematic achievement. Braveheart won five oscars, including best picture. It even beat out 10,000 bc which, like anonymous, was directed by roland. At least as a young man who is confused and mixed up as to his. Historian elizabeth ewan describes braveheart as a film which almost totally sacrifices historical accuracy for epic adventure. Despite braveheart s false pretenses, it is undeniably a lovable movie. Braveheart the 10 historical inaccuracies you need to know. Historical inaccuracy in braveheart 865 words bartleby.
The character of robert bruce in the film is probably the only one they got reasonably accurate. The bad news is, pretty much everything else in braveheart is wrong. Nov, 2018 braveheart has been called one of the least accurate historical movies ever made, a harsh critique when you consider films like 10,000 bc, pocahontas, jfk, and pearl harbor. Braveheart won five oscars including for best picture and best makeup, but oscar for best costume design went to less famous movie restoration. One of the most common questions im asked is how factual mel gibsons portrayal of william wallace was in the 1995 film braveheart. The most historically inaccurate movies ever readers digest. For fans who love history, this film will immerse you in a time when the coliseum was the pinnacle of entertainment, and men fought to the death, all in the name of. Historical inaccuracies in the movie braveheart free essays. Here we have an interesting problem, where movies that are more historically correct and ones that are not, are both enjoyed. These 20 historical inaccuracies in braveheart just. No face paints, no kilts, or historical inaccuracies can be compared to the crime of that first sentence. Though the chemistry between leo and kate is palpable onscreen, titanic compromises historical accuracy for its romantic fantasy. Historical accuracy in films and the tiffany problem just.
At the end of the day, one of the key elements of whether a movie s historical accuracy matters comes down to each specific audience member. Braveheart was a popular movie released in 1995 that won 5 oscars and featured mel gibson as william wallace. The movie was a surprise winner of the academy award for best picture. Whether they were cinematic choices or somebody skipped out on researching, the movie is basically made up. The 1995 movie, braveheart, is a cinematic masterpiece. A heartstirring and carefully crafted piece of storytelling, it won five oscars. A multiple oscar winner, an aweinspiring cinematic portrayal of scottish freedom. Gibson received an oscar for best director, and the film received four additional oscars including best picture and five nominations, and several other film industry awards. Mel gibsons braveheart is fullblood medieval action movie based on life and death of scottish national hero william wallace, scottish personal che guevara. There are lots of great battles, bagpipes, men in kilts, and epic speeches given by mel gibson with a questionable scottish accent. Nov 03, 2016 it won multiple oscars, praised by film critics and adored by audiences. When ridley scott released his crusade epic kingdom of heaven in 2005, his film provoked widespread controversy from historians and derision from film critics.
The films historical denigrators were divided into muslim. Braveheart is a 1995 american epic historical fiction war film directed and coproduced by mel gibson, who portrays william wallace, a latethcentury scottish warrior. A multiple oscar winner, an aweinspiring cinematic portrayal of scottish freedom fighter william wallace and his greatest accomplishments. What are some historical inaccuracies in braveheart. Outlaw king vs braveheart on historical accuracy popular mechanics.
Braveheart is a dramatic film that has nothing to do actual history. Aug 28, 20 as recently as 2009, the times of london called braveheart the secondmost inaccurate historical film of all time. May 24, 2012 gibson both directed and starred in the 1995 film that depicted the true story of a rebellious scottish warrior, william wallace, as he led an uprising against the king of england, edward i, during the th century. But how close did it stay to what actually happened. That is where disney pixars 2012 animated film, brave falls on the scale.
1437 1582 80 256 771 674 1278 226 784 66 606 939 607 731 162 701 713 1361 11 1005 770 747 851 965 418 938 601 1200 269 521 1169 47 215 549 416 1229 559 381 1405 1095 910 1414 579 778 433 1459 1469 1229 304